Conservation in Court

The judge upheld the endangered listing of this species, after a lawsuit was filed in an attempt to strip it of the protection it desperately needs.

Image: By Ansgar Walk (photo taken by Ansgar Walk) [CC-BY-SA-2.5 (], via Wikimedia Commons

The enchanting Cook Inlet beluga whale, icon of Alaska and famous for its melodious song, received a helping hand in November from a federal judge.  The judge upheld the endangered listing of this species, after a lawsuit was filed in an attempt to strip it of the protection it desperately needs.

The Cook Inlet beluga whale is a genetically distinct and geographically isolated species, confined only to Cook Inlet in southern Alaska. Its population has plummeted in the past 20 years, from 1300 to just 321 individuals. The population continued to decline even after subsistence whaling of this species was banned in 1999, due to the additional threats of offshore oil development, ship strikes and noise pollution.

Listed as endangered in 2008

In response to their fall in numbers, the Cook Inlet beluga was listed as endangered in 2008 under the US Endangered Species Act, and over 3000 square miles of the Cook Inlet was designated as critical habitat. Shortly after however, the then Governor of Alaska Sarah Palin announced that she would sue over the listing, a move many saw as politically motivated. In June 2010, a lawsuit was filed in court claiming that the whale was in no need of protection.

This lawsuit was defeated last month. The judge rejected all of the state’s arguments and affirmed that the original listing recommended by the National Marine Fisheries Service was based on the best available science. He also noted that Alaska’s programmes to conserve the beluga whale are ineffective and underfunded, with most efforts providing only “incidental” benefit.

The Center for Biological Diversity, an organisation that has been fighting to protect this species for more than a decade, is celebrating the victory. They point out that the state’s time and money would have been better spent trying to remove the beluga from the endangered list by enhancing conservation efforts, rather than fighting the Endangered Species Act in court. The state is taking a similar tack for other imperilled Alaskan species, such as the polar bear and Steller sea lions, so there will be more lawsuits to come. In the meantime though, with protection secured, the Cook Inlet beluga whale may stand a chance of recovery.


No comments yet.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.*

Tick the box or answer the captcha.

You might also like

  • Wolverines Face Courtroom Battle

    Their extremely low numbers mean that they are suffering from low genetic diversity, their habitat is being fragmented, trapping still occurs and human disturbance from snowmobiling and backcountry skiing disrupts denning wolverines.

    By Alex Taylor
  • Bycatch Responsible for Decline of Sea Lion

    Scientists studying the decline of the New Zealand sea lion have linked it to commercial fisheries bycatch around their breeding colonies on the Auckland Islands, which has previously been assumed to be only a minor threat.

    By Alex Taylor
  • Return of the Yak

    Conservationists believe that this is down to efforts by Chinese park officials and provincial governments. The Qinghai provincial government, for example, recently launched several conservation-related policies and region-wide projects that aim to build a foundation for wildlife conservation.

    By Alex Taylor